La Cucina Paisanos Review

A freshly baked pepperoni pizza with a golden crust, served on a wooden board with steam rising, surrounded by fresh tomatoes and beans.
Fresh out of the oven! La Cucina Paisanos in Farmingville serves up delicious, house-made pizza with a perfect crispy crust.

My wife and I checked out the new La Cucina Paisanos in Farmingville this past Monday (1/28/25). After hearing lots of buzz about it on Sachem Mom’s Facebook Group, we were excited to see what all the hype was about—and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

We arrived around 7:30 PM and were warmly greeted by a friendly server who quickly got us seated. Along with the regular menu, we were handed their special “Pasta Night” menu, available every Monday. For just $22.95, Pasta Night includes a house salad, an entrée, dessert, and coffee—a deal that’s hard to beat!

Unlike other places that keep Pasta Night pretty basic, La Cucina takes it to the next level with dishes that include actual meat and seafood options. I went with the Chicken Marsala, while my wife chose the Shrimp Fra Diavolo—both excellent choices. While we decided, our server brought over a bread basket with seasoned olive oil for dipping. The bread? All house-made, with several varieties, and absolutely delicious.

When our entrées arrived, we were immediately impressed by the generous portions—and the taste matched the presentation. Both dishes were flavorful and cooked to perfection. We also really enjoyed the cozy, friendly atmosphere. The owner, Lindsey, took the time to visit every table, including ours, to make sure everything was perfect (spoiler: it was!).

To top off an already great night, as we were leaving, Lindsey stopped us at the door and offered us a couple of pizza slices to take home—on the house! Since it was late, they had leftover General Tso pizza they couldn’t serve the next day. Our son tried the slices when we got home, and he absolutely loved them.

All in all, we had a fantastic experience at La Cucina Paisanos, from the delicious food to the warm and welcoming service. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!


Visit La Cucina Paisanos at:
1075 Portion Rd, Suite 27-W
Farmingville, NY 11738
Phone: 631.676.4588


If you’re a local business owner looking to enhance your online presence, having a professionally designed website is essential. At Hassle Free Websites, we specialize in Web Design Long Island, creating fully managed, hassle-free websites that help small businesses attract more customers and grow their brand. Whether you’re a restaurant like La Cucina Paisanos or a service provider, a well-designed website can showcase your offerings, build credibility, and make it easy for customers to connect with you. Let us handle your website so you can focus on what you do best—running your business!

Get your Hassle-free website today

Maximum impact, Zero stress.

$195/month
100% Secure Checkout